On the subject of the dispute between Universal Music Group and TikTok over royalty funds – the discuss of the music business over the previous few weeks – Warner Music Group CEO Robert Kyncl is providing some cautionary recommendation: “No matter you learn within the press, don’t consider it.”
Kyncl made the touch upon WMG’s earnings name on Thursday (February 8), by which analysts typically appeared as concerned about speaking in regards to the UMG-TikTok state of affairs as they had been in WMG’s (somewhat spectacular) fiscal Q1 numbers.
Kyncl famous that, in his prior position as Chief Enterprise Officer at YouTube, he had himself skilled some of these rightsholder-vs.-platform conflicts, “so I do know precisely what Lucian and Shou are feeling,” he stated, referring to UMG Chairman and CEO Sir Lucian Grainge and TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew.
Common’s recorded music catalog (about 3 million tracks) and its publishing catalog (almost 4 million songs) have started to disappear from TikTok, after TikTok’s licensing settlement with UMG expired on January 31, with no new settlement in place.
As that deadline handed, the rhetoric between the short-video social media platform and the world’s largest music rights holder grew more and more heated.
Kyncl was CBO at YouTube throughout a interval, round a decade in the past, when the main music corporations would frequently bemoan the dimensions of royalty checks coming their method from Google‘s video platform. (Trade relations with YouTube subsequently turned far more harmonious.)
With that have in thoughts, Kyncl stated he stays “assured” that UMG and TikTok will type out their points.
“I’m assured that they’ll – sooner or later – discover an settlement as a result of, going from [Kyncl’s own] YouTube expertise, music is extremely useful to virality and content material,” he stated. “Individuals once they’re creating content material, they love developments, they love music… clearly, that’s invaluable to a platform.”
He added: “Conversely, TikTok, YouTube, Reels – all of these platforms are clearly useful to creating music in style. All of us love that on the music facet. And [TikTok’s] person engagement is nice.”
Kyncl continued: “Clearly, I’ve an curiosity in [UMG and TikTok] working it out. I would like them to work it out. And I feel they’re each cheap folks that can discover a compromise.”
Kyncl added that he felt WMG’s personal present cope with TikTok – announced in July 2023 – was “honest”.
He burdened that WMG’s newest TikTok licensing settlement mirrored a technique whereby “we don’t comply with different corporations. We don’t do carbon copies of different offers. We do our personal, which is why we did the [TikTok] one final 12 months… It wasn’t straightforward with TikTok. I feel it was very tough [negotiation]. However we bought there.”
Warner CFO, Bryan Castellani, stated that the rewards from Warner’s 2023 TikTok deal had “contributed” to a 10% YoY uplift in ad-supported recorded music streaming income at WMG within the three months to finish of December.
Kyncl and Castellani’s feedback arrived as Warner Music Group reported its biggest-ever quarter in its fiscal Q1 (calendar This autumn), which ended on December 31, 2023.
The corporate reported USD $1.748 billion in world revenues in calendar This autumn, up 10.6% YoY on a normalized, fixed forex foundation. (That’s ‘normalized’ because it omits a one-time $13 million unfavourable QoQ impression from WMG’s distribution break up with BMG, and likewise omits two one-time advantages from unnamed recorded music license renewals/extensions.)
WMG’s quarterly recorded music streaming revenues jumped 11.4% YoY (on a normalized, fixed forex foundation) to $887 million, whereas music publishing streaming revenues had been up by 30.4% YoY (on a relentless forex foundation) to $193 million.
At present’s earnings name additionally arrived after Warner’s announcement Wednesday that it’s laying off around 600 staff, or about 10% of its workforce – a transfer that Kyncl stated on the earnings name is a part of an effectivity drive that can save the corporate $200 million by September 2025.
The vast majority of these layoffs will happen inside WMG’s ‘owned and operated’ media properties, a few of which the corporate plans to promote.
“We’re in an unique course of for the potential sale of the information leisure web sites Uproxx and HipHopDX, with extra to say on that quickly,” Kyncl instructed analysts on the decision.
Listed here are three different issues we discovered on Warner Music Group’s earnings name…
1) The financial savings from job reductions can be invested into music and ‘automation’ of inside processes
Warner will minimize round 600 workers by the tip of September, the corporate confirmed this week.
Kyncl instructed analysts in the present day that the $200 million saved from this headcount discount can be put primarily in the direction of music investments, the place there are “various alternatives that we are able to’t absolutely materialize as a result of [of] how we handle our stability sheet, our dividend… working responsibly.” With the brand new financial savings, he stated, “we have now much more alternatives that we are able to successfully afford.”
Nonetheless, Kyncl additionally stated that a number of the financial savings would go into tech improvements, together with AI-powered applied sciences.
“It’s actually necessary that tech is supporting environment friendly progress of the corporate, and introducing as a lot automation as doable into our programs and processes, each on the recorded facet in addition to on the publishing facet. It additionally helps us monetize our whole catalog,” he stated.
“It’s actually necessary that tech is supporting environment friendly progress of the corporate, and introducing as a lot automation as doable into our programs and processes, each on the recorded facet in addition to on the publishing facet.”
Robert Kyncl, Warner Music Group
As one instance, Kyncl pointed to thumbnails that go together with tracks uploaded to music streaming providers.
“Freshness of thumbnails, or movement artwork, issues of that nature, assist streams which helps income, however it’s actually tough to do this manually throughout such a big quantity of content material. So we developed an AI instrument that helps us replace and create new ones,” he stated.
“So there are many methods of this commerce, [and] we are able to deploy the know-how to assist monitor income as properly.”
2) Spotify’s new royalty cost mannequin is ‘only the start’
Over the previous a number of months, we’ve seen some vital adjustments to the way in which sure streaming music providers pay royalties, particularly Deezer’s shift to an “artist-centric” model, underneath which “skilled artists” – those that have a minimal of 1,000 streams monthly and a minimal of 500 distinctive listeners – obtain a so-called “double enhance” to royalty funds, as do artists whose tracks have been actively looked for by customers.
Not lengthy after that transfer, Spotify unveiled a new payment model underneath which a monitor must be performed a minimal of 1,000 occasions in a 12-month interval with the intention to qualify for funds from Spotify’s pool of royalty cash.
On WMG’s earnings name, Kyncl referred to as Spotify’s transfer “a step in the fitting course” that “higher aligns economics with the standard content material that drives engagement. We view this as only the start and we’re frequently engaged with our companions to drive sooner [revenue] progress.”
“We must be not solely searching, however we also needs to be harvesting.”
Robert Kyncl, Warner Music Group
Kyncl, who has argued repeatedly over the previous 12 months that streamed music is undervalued, can also be pushing for additional value hikes on the DSPs, calling it “certainly one of our very massive alternatives.” He prompt that the time has come to focus not solely subscriber progress, however on income progress as properly.
“The way in which I discuss it’s, we must be not solely searching, however we also needs to be harvesting. The business clearly has centered on progress during the last 15 years [and now] we simply have to do each of these issues… and be way more intentional about that.”
Driving sooner income progress is a part of Kyncl’s three-pronged strategy for WMG over the subsequent decade, which consists of rising engagement with music, rising the worth of music, and evolving how WMG’s workers work collectively.
Driving adjustments to the royalty cost fashions at streaming providers is a part of the technique to extend the worth of music, as is “strengthening our artists’ direct relationships with their superfans… We’ll speed up the constructing of our new merchandise and experiences, because it’s an space that’s comparatively untapped and under-monetized,” Kyncl stated.
3) The digital music period is making massive music corporations like WMG ‘exponentially extra related’
With the arrival of digital platforms (notably ones open to everybody, like YouTube and SoundCloud), digital audio workstations, and indie distribution providers like DistroKid and SoundOn, it’s turning into more and more straightforward and sensible for artists to “go DIY,” as a substitute of hoping for a break at a significant file label.
Which, in fact, begs the query: Will massive music corporations even be related sooner or later?
In Kyncl’s view, not solely will they be related – they are going to be extra related than ever.
“Because the music enterprise has grown bigger, sooner, noisier, and extra advanced, with democratized distribution making a flood of content material on platforms, the position of huge music corporations is rising exponentially extra related,” he stated on the earnings name.
“It’s tougher than ever for anyone artist to interrupt via the muddle. And that’s the place we are available. We accumulate and course of massive volumes of information and make it usable and actionable, driving repeatable outcomes – a job that could be very tough for any particular person artist or small enterprise, due to the sources and ability units it requires.
“Our world advertising footprint and experience, mixed with deep technical capabilities to construct programs and knowledge insights, allow us to distinguish ourselves on this regard. In truth, wanting on the final quarter, songs from the main music label teams represented 94% of the songs on Billboard Scorching 100.”
“Because the music enterprise has grown bigger, sooner, noisier, and extra advanced, with democratized distribution making a flood of content material on platforms, the position of huge music corporations is rising exponentially extra related.”
Robert Kyncl, Warner Music Group
That’s a fairly convincing argument to not guess in opposition to the main file corporations, and it’s some extent that Kyncl has made, in numerous methods, earlier than.
On the Code Convention in California final September, Kyncl laid out an argument for why artists nonetheless want file labels. He drew a parallel between the music enterprise in the present day and the promoting enterprise a decade or two in the past, when it appeared like advert businesses may go extinct within the age of Google AdWords, which allowed anybody to customise their very own advert marketing campaign from the consolation of their laptop computer.
But advert businesses didn’t disappear, and in the present day,, “they’re the most important prospects of corporations like Google,” Kyncl stated.
“What occurred was plenty of totally different platforms emerged. Plenty of advert tech emerged, complexity elevated exponentially, and [businesses] wanted assist with that, and the businesses supplied that worth.”
It’s the identical in the present day with file labels, he argued.
“Music is extremely broadly distributed… And the complexity is excessive. And the extra folks can add content material, and the extra folks might be heard, the higher the noise, which implies it’s tougher to chop via the noise and maintain a profession.”
When you’re a music artist, “you want a group. You want a military behind you…. in order for you a sustainable profession, with repeatability and success.”
JKBX (pronounced “Jukebox”) unlocks shared value from things people love by offering consumers access to music as an asset class — it calls them Royalty Shares. In short: JKBX makes it possible for you to invest in music the same way you invest in stocks and other securities.Music Enterprise Worldwide